Two people can see the same Broadway show and walk away with completely different reasons for wanting to see it. One might be drawn to the cast, another to the story and someone else to its cultural relevance. So why should our digital advertising approach assume they all respond to the same message?
Reaching the right audience is only part of the equation. Understanding what motivates them to buy is just as important. With today’s digital platforms, audience insights, behavioral data and increasingly sophisticated targeting capabilities, we have more opportunities to move beyond traditional audience segments and build campaigns around what actually drives interest and ticket sales.
The challenge is turning those insights into smarter media strategies that reach people for the right reasons, at the right time.
Rethinking how we target audiences
Traditionally, digital advertising has relied on interests, demographics and online behavior to identify potential customers. When promoting a Broadway show, for example, we might target people interested in theater, live entertainment or similar productions.
But knowing someone likes Broadway doesn’t necessarily tell us what will convince them to see a particular show.
Platforms like Meta are increasingly using automated targeting, allowing their systems to identify people most likely to engage with an ad or make a purchase. Instead of relying entirely on interests selected by advertisers, these systems analyze user behavior and campaign results to find potential customers.
This makes creative (the images, videos and messages used in ads) an important part of audience targeting. Different messages can attract different people, giving platforms more opportunities to identify who is likely to respond.
Consider Off-Broadway’s “Rope” as an example. This suspenseful psychological thriller is a new adaptation of the play that inspired Alfred Hitchcock’s iconic film of the same name. Rather than creating separate campaigns for predefined audience segments, we could test several creative and messaging angles within the same campaign. Here’s how those approaches might translate into advertising copy:
- Classic mystery: Highlighting its connection to Alfred Hitchcock and the murder mystery genre to attract film enthusiasts and thriller fans.
- Example ad copy: “Newly adapted by Gordon Greenberg from the play that inspired Hitchcock’s iconic film ROPE”