Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s “The Fantasticks” ran for 42 consecutive years Off-Broadway and is widely considered the world’s longest-running musical. And while its longevity has become the musical’s calling card, there was a reason beyond stasis that the show ran for decades. Ask the cast and creative team of its first-ever Broadway mounting, which officially opens on Nov. 16 at Second Stage’s Helen Hayes Theatre, about what makes “The Fantasticks” special and enduring and you’ll get a version of the same answer: its complex simplicity.
“What they wrote originally is so simple and beautiful,” said director-choreographer Christopher Gattelli, “that I think the reason why people connect to it is because it’s not so overly specific that you can’t relate to the characters. There’s enough information about them to give you what you need, but not overly so. You see yourself in every character at some point in the show because you can, you have access to that.” Indeed, there is a poeticism and whimsy in the DNA of “The Fantasticks” — depth and straightforwardness.